Fake Plugs

We stock a wide selection of fake plugs that will fit traditionally pierced ear lobes. All body jewelry designs in this collection are sold as pairs.

30 of 41 products
Sort by:
Best selling
Acrylic Fake Plugs
Acrylic Fake Plugs Fake Plugs

Acrylic Fake Plugs

16g 1/4"
7 colors
Price
$3.98
pair
Acrylic Fake Tapers
Acrylic Fake Tapers Fake Plugs 16g - 1/4" long (6mm) Pink

Acrylic Fake Tapers

16g 1/4"
6 colors
Price
$5.98
pair
Stainless Fake Plugs
Stainless Fake Plugs Fake Plugs 16g - 1/4" long (6mm) Stainless Steel

Stainless Fake Plugs

16g 1/4"
Price
$5.98
pair
Star Fake Plugs
50% off
Star Fake Plugs Fake Plugs 18g - 1/4" long (6mm) Purple Star on White

Star Fake Plugs

18 gauge - 1/4" long
Closeout!
Regular price
$5.98
Sale price
$2.99
pair
Multi-CZ Fake Plugs
Multi-CZ Fake Plugs Fake Plugs 16g - 1/4" long (6mm) Clear/Clear

Multi-CZ Fake Plugs

16g 1/4"
5 gem colors
Price
$8.98
pair
Dragon Fake Hangers
Dragon Fake Hangers Fake Plugs 16g - 1/4" long (6mm) White

Dragon Fake Hangers

16g 1/4"
black or white
Price
$8.98
pair
Glow-in-the-Dark Fake Plugs
50% off
Glow-in-the-Dark Fake Plugs Fake Plugs 16g - 1/4" long (6mm) Light Green

Glow-in-the-Dark Fake Plugs

16g 1/4"
3 colors
Regular price
$5.98
Sale price
$2.99
pair
Acrylic CZ Fake Tapers
Acrylic CZ Fake Tapers Fake Plugs 16g - 1/4" long (6mm) Black / Clear CZ

Acrylic CZ Fake Tapers

16g 1/4"
9 colors
Price
$6.98
pair
Stainless Fake Tapers
Stainless Fake Tapers Fake Plugs 16g - 1/4" long (6mm) Stainless Steel

Stainless Fake Tapers

16g 1/4"
Price
$9.98
pair
PVD Coated Fake Tapers
PVD Coated Fake Tapers Fake Plugs 16g - 1/4" long (6mm) Black

PVD Coated Fake Tapers

16g 1/4"
5 colors
Price
$8.98
pair
Vine CZ Fake Plugs
Vine CZ Fake Plugs Fake Plugs 16g - 1/4" long (6mm) Clear

Vine CZ Fake Plugs

16g 1/4"
Price
$11.98
pair
Dumbbell Stainless Fake Plugs
Dumbbell Stainless Fake Plugs Fake Plugs 16g - 1/4" long (6mm) Stainless Steel

Dumbbell Stainless Fake Plugs

16g 1/4"
Price
$7.98
pair
U.S. Military Fake Plugs
50% off
U.S. Military Fake Plugs Fake Plugs 16g - 1/4" long (6mm) U.S. Army

U.S. Military Fake Plugs

16g 1/4"
4 logos
Regular price
$5.98
Sale price
$2.99
pair
Checkered Fake Spirals
Checkered Fake Spirals Fake Plugs 16 gauge - 1/4" long Black & White

Checkered Fake Spirals

16g 1/4"
Price
$8.98
pair
Purple Plaid Fake Plugs
Purple Plaid Fake Plugs Fake Plugs 18g - 1/4" long (6mm) Stainless Steel

Purple Plaid Fake Plugs

18g 1/4"
Price
$7.98
pair
Flaming Fake Spirals
50% off
Flaming Fake Spirals Fake Plugs 18 gauge Black

Flaming Fake Spirals

18g
Regular price
$8.98
Sale price
$4.49
pair